HOME > BLOG
The Ultimate Escape-Proof Dog Crate Comparison: Which Type Actually Works?
Published February 27, 2025
Save
This post is in partnership with Impact Dog Crates. I only endorse products I believe in.
After my German Shepherd destroyed his fifth crate—and my living room—I knew I needed a real solution. I tested every "escape-proof" crate I could find, including Impact Dog Crates, standard wire crates, "heavy-duty" wire crates, plastic airline crates, and furniture-style wooden crates. My goal: Find the one that could finally contain my determined dog.
Impact Dog Crates
When I was at my wit’s end, Impact Dog Crates was the only crate that truly delivered on its promise. My dog is a professional-level escape artist, and no other crate could hold him—until this one. I loved that it was made with aircraft-grade aluminum and military-spec hardware. There were no cheap plastic parts, and I couldn’t find a single weak spot. While it was pricier than other crates, I quickly realized how much I saved by not having to replace broken crates, fix damaged furniture, or pay for emergency vet visits. The peace of mind it gave me was worth every penny.
Standard Wire Crates
I bought a standard wire crate early on, thinking it would be enough to keep my dog safe. I was so wrong. Within minutes, he had bent the thin wires and popped the latch. The crate looked like it had been through a tornado, and my dog was happily greeting me at the door. I quickly learned that these crates are no match for a strong, determined dog. Worse, the broken wires created dangerous sharp points, making me worry about injuries.
Plastic Airline Crates
When I tried a plastic airline crate, I hoped the solid walls would make it harder for my dog to break out. But he had other plans. He chewed through the plastic and pushed the door off within a couple of hours. While it was safer for his teeth than wire crates, the plastic shards became a new danger. I realized these crates might work for a quick car ride, but they weren’t designed for a dog with my pup’s escape skills.
Furniture-Style Wooden Crates
I wanted a crate that looked nice in my home, so I tried a furniture-style wooden crate. It was beautiful—until my dog decided to redecorate. He chewed through the wood, splintering it all over the floor. Not only did he escape quickly, but I was also worried about him ingesting wood or getting splinters. It became clear that these crates are more about style than security, and I couldn’t trust them to keep my dog safe.
The Verdict: Impact Dog Crates Are Worth It
After testing all these crates, Impact Dog Crates was the only one that truly delivered. I stopped coming home to destroyed furniture and didn’t have to worry about my dog injuring himself. While the upfront cost was higher, I quickly realized how much money I saved by avoiding damaged furniture, emergency vet visits, and constantly replacing broken crates. Plus, the lifetime warranty gave me even more peace of mind. It felt like a weight lifted off my shoulders. If you have an escape artist like I do, Impact Dog Crates is the only choice that really works.